About Gimmeitam

Built by Collectors,
for Collectors

Gimmeitam is your trusted source for premium trading cards, graded collectibles, and everything in between.

Our Story

Gimmeitam started the way every great card shop does — at a kitchen table. A couple of collectors, stacks of binders, and one shared obsession: finding the cleanest cards at fair prices. We spent years hunting through local shops, online marketplaces, and card shows, and we kept running into the same problems — questionable authenticity, inflated prices, and sellers who didn't actually care about the hobby.

So we built something better. What started as a small side hustle selling from our personal collections grew into a full-scale operation dedicated to doing things the right way. Every card that passes through our hands is inspected, verified, and priced competitively. No shortcuts, no guesswork.

Today, Gimmeitam serves thousands of collectors across the country — from people ripping their first pack to seasoned graders building six-figure portfolios. The hobby has changed, but our mission hasn't: make it easy to find the cards you want from a source you can trust.

Team / Store Photo

What We Stand For

Three principles that guide everything we do.

Authenticity First

Every card is verified. Every grade is authenticated. We work exclusively with trusted grading services and maintain strict quality control so you never have to second-guess what you're buying.

Collector Community

We're collectors too. We know the thrill of a chase card and the pain of a bad pull. That shared passion drives how we curate our inventory and support the community around the hobby.

Fair Pricing

Market-competitive prices on every product, every day. No hype markups, no price gouging during set releases. We track the market in real-time so you always get a fair deal.

10,000+
Cards Sold
4.9★
Customer Rating
50+
Game Brands
24hr
Shipping Turnaround

The Gimmeitam Promise

Every order goes through our multi-step quality process. Cards are inspected for condition accuracy, graded slabs are verified against grading company databases, and every item is securely packaged with collector-grade protection. From the moment you place your order to the second it arrives at your door, we treat your cards the way we'd want ours treated.

Authenticity Guaranteed
Every card verified against grading databases. Fakes never make it to our shelves.
Free Shipping $150+
Fast, tracked shipping on every order. Free over $150 within the US.
Easy Returns
Not what you expected? Hassle-free returns within 30 days, no questions asked.
Secure Payments
SSL-encrypted checkout with Visa, Mastercard, Amex, PayPal, and Apple Pay.